One thing that might have made Captain America: Brave New World a better film, or at least a better moviegoing experience, would have been a final act surprise. Imagine if Disney hadn’t marketed the hell out of the Red Hulk and we hadn’t known going into the movie that Harrison Ford’s president Ross was going to turn into the Red Hulk. If that hadn’t been spoiled in the marketing, it might have been a really fun twist. Instead, we just waited around to see when it would happen and then watched a big fight scene and then that was that. Light spoilers ahead.
Captain America: Brave New World isn’t the best or the worst MCU film. It has some genuinely fun action scenes. There’s a good political thriller buried in the overstuffed plot. Anthony Mackie did a really great job as Captain America, and as someone who is generally not a huge fan of Mackie, I’m happy to report that he really grew on me here.
But outside of Mackie and Ford and some strong but brief moments with both Giancarlo Esposito’s Seth Voelker and Tim Blake Nelson’s Samuel Sterns, the movie is just a convoluted mess. I’ve already listed three villains: Voelker, Sterns and Red Hulk / Ross, though Ross is less of a villain and more of a well-meaning antagonist and Red Hulk is just a natural disaster. I’m already having trouble keeping track of all these bad guys, plus the new good guys introduced, and the characters from past MCU shows. The more I thought about this movie after seeing it, the less I liked it, because the more I realized how little any of it matters.
So much is going on in Brave New World it’s honestly hard to keep up, and the plot is just go, go, go from the start. There are various factions and alliances and treaties and conflicts and all of them come at you fast, relentlessly, like the film is worried that if it ever slows down people might pay too much attention. Despite tons and tons of exposition to keep audiences up to speed (and to help clue them in on what’s going on since many likely missed The Eternals and Falcon and the Winter Soldier) the whole thing is just clunky as hell.
It’s also hard to really care about any of it. I don’t care about Ross and his estranged daughter. I don’t really care about the international relationships between the US and Japan (seriously, Japan?) and the rest of the world powers. I don’t really understand why the Celestial is filled with Adamantium, either. Surely all this does is cheapen Wolverine?